Apologeet.nl
How the Self-Help-Culture Deceives Many ChristiansIntro
Does an obsession with becoming a ‘better’ Christian, fuelled by self-help books and productivity hacks, leave you spiritually exhausted? But what if I told you that this very fixation might be pulling you away from Christ — not closer to Him? This is what the so-called self-help movement is doing! All these books and videos promise spiritual growth, confidence, and even success—and I might even have contributed to that thinking with some of my videos!
In reality, the self-help message can be a huge obstacle for Christians to grow as it seems to be in conflict with the message of the Gospel. The self-help message is a trap wrapped in a Christian package.
Today, we’re exposing how the self-help mentality is a deception that can lead us away from true Christianity. And some of these lies sound so biblical… you might have believed them without even realising it I’ll show you three signs which might indicate that you are being discipled more by the do-it-yourself culture than by the Holy Spirit.
The Gospel of ‘Me’
But first, let’s find out what this so-called ‘help-yourself’ idea actually achieves. You see, our culture is obsessed with the message of self-improvement: ‘You are enough’, ‘You have the power within you.’ But could it be that this mindset is replacing God with yourself — without you noticing? These messages have been repackaged with a thin Christian veneer. The core problem is that the gospel of self-help places you at the centre. It’s about your potential and your ability to transform yourself. This creates serious spiritual pitfalls.
It basically replaces God’s power with our own. The Christian life begins by admitting we can’t save ourselves. Self-reliance is rooted in pride. This might be hard to hear… but trusting in yourself might actually be the reason your faith feels dry. The Bible warns in Jeremiah 17:5
Cursed is the one who trusts in man, who draws strength from mere flesh and whose heart turns away from the Lord.
Self-help tells you to pull yourself up by your bootstraps; the Gospel says you don’t even have boots—Jesus is the one who lifts you up.
But you know what? It also twists God’s character into a transaction. Much ‘Christian’ self-help implies that following a five-step plan will make God bless you. This treats God’s grace like a reward for our hard work, not a free gift. It reduces God to a resource for achieving the life we want, instead of the Lord we’re called to obey.
Also, the self-help gospel replaces the cross with the self. It shifts our focus from repentance to self-affirmation. Culture says, “follow your heart,” but Scripture warns in Jeremiah 17:9 that “The heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure.” Self-help tells you to look inward. Christianity tells you to look to Christ.
The result of this self-help spirituality isn’t peace; it’s a crushing pressure to perform. You live with constant anxiety that you’re not doing enough, or you’re not doing it ‘spiritually’ enough.
Let me ask you this: Are you sure you’re being discipled by the Holy Spirit — or by Instagram influencers and self-help gurus?
The Signs
Okay, with that out of the way, let’s look at three warning signs.
#1 – High Productivity
The first sign has everything to do with your productivity. The self-help culture is all about output. The more you do yourself, the better you’ll become.
Here’s the trap: You can be doing everything right and still be completely disconnected from God.
You pride yourself in waking very early to start the day; you’ll show everybody at work that you can do double shifts; besides studying you are to hotshot on the sport-field; in church or at youth club you are the busiest of them all.
Whatever you do, you do it 200% and you’re crushing it! But at the meantime you don’t feel at ease; you miss that loving peace you’re longing for.
True peace comes not from being highly productive, it comes from God.
Philippians 4:7
And the peace of God, which transcends all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.
#2 – Checklist
The second sign? You’ve put Jesus, like all other things in your life, on a to-do list. Most of the time you go to bed and find out that you almost managed to tick all the boxes of this checklist, except the last box: Time with Jesus.
If you’ve ever ended the day realising you’ve done everything except spend time with Jesus… this one might hit hard.
What was number one of this list? Read an extra chapter from ‘The Purpose Driven Life’ by Rick Warren? What was number two on your list? Watch that 50 minutes video from John Piper?
I guess you get the point, don’t you? Your checklist should contain one big bullet-point: Prioritise scripture and prayer over everything!
#3 — Not Opening the Bible
The third is that your Bible remains closed. You’re reading every single book about spiritual growth and watch all possible video you can find. They teach you all the steps you need to take to be more successful, and you spend all your time perfecting these new techniques, but you’re spending very little time reading the Bible.
The Bible is the infallible word of God, and it will change you when you read it. The Lord God is actually talking to your through His word. The books you read and the videos you watch can be helpful, but they can never replace the Word of God.
This might shock you: The more you rely on ‘Christian content’ over God’s Word, the more spiritually malnourished you actually become.
If you spend more time in these books you risk missing out on real transformation, and that places you in a risky situation.
Paul clearly tells us in 2 Timothy 3:16
All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness
There is no technique in this world which can compete with God’s word, the Bible.
Subtle Danger of Replacing the Gospel
This mindset mirrors an ancient heresy, Pelagianism, which over-emphasises human effort and downplays our need for God’s grace. If you don’t know about this heresy you can click on the video below or go to the article on this website.
We start to believe our sanctification—the process of becoming more like Christ—depends entirely on us. But what if your endless striving is actually blocking God’s grace in your life?
Often, this isn’t true spiritual growth; it’s just behaviour modification. It’s like re-painting a house that has a broken foundation. It might look better, but the structure is still crumbling.
The self-help sector flourishes on a notion that appears uplifting yet poses spiritual risks: "You possess the inner strength to transform your life."
The self-help culture is the opposite of what the Bible teaches us. It says “Believe in yourself.” as opposed to Matthew 16:24 “Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me”. The do-it-yourself books want you to believe that you are enough in yourself but the Bible teaches us that it is Christ Who is enough. But also, these ideas tell you that the things you do must give you happiness in the first place. But we read in Matthew 6:33 “But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness”.
The Turning Point
The turning point comes from reading Jesus’ words in John 15:5: “I am the vine; you are the branches. If you remain in me and I in you, you will bear much fruit; apart from me you can do nothing.”
Apart from me, you can do nothing. Those seven words can change everything… if you truly believe them.
Those words should stop us in our tracks. Not, "you can do a few things," but nothing. All our striving and white-knuckled effort can amount to nothing. We can be trying to bear fruit while disconnected from the vine.
The realization hits that the self-help project is built on the same lie from the Garden of Eden: that if you take matters into your own hands, you can be like God. But Christianity isn’t about self-improvement; it’s about self-abandonment. Jesus says in Luke 9:23, "Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me." The goal isn’t to become your ‘best self’; the goal is to die to yourself so that Christ can live through you, as Paul writes in Galatians 2:20
I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I now live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.
A Biblical Take on the Self-Help Frenzy
The self-help books and videos are not inherently wrong. They can be a great help. However, we need to harness our dependency on them. And here’s the good news: God doesn’t want you trapped in a hamster wheel of spiritual burnout. We need to cultivate a real dependence on God!
#1 – Evaluate your Sources.
When you engage with content, ask: does this point me to my own strength or to God’s grace? Is it consistent with what the Bible teaches about sin, grace, and Jesus? God’s Word is our primary source of truth! We need to look at all other thing in the light of the Bible.
#2 – Check your Motives
Are you trying to grow to make your life more comfortable, or to glorify God and serve others? Christian discipline is to increase our ability to love God and our neighbour.
#3 – Focus on the Gospel Every Day
The Christian life begins when you admit you can’t save yourself and trust in Jesus. Remind yourself of that truth daily. Your value is in who you are in Christ and not in what others think of you, or even what you might think of yourself.
#4 – Seek out Real Community.
Don’t do this alone. Isolated self-help is a trap. Get involved in a local church where Scripture, prayer, and honest relationships are central. That’s where real growth happens.
#5 – Use Self-Help Tools, but don’t Overdo it!
Read books, watch biblical channels on YouTube, and put some good habits into place—but build your trust on these things. In my last video I mention some good habits to come closer to the Lord. You’ll find the this video below or you can go to the article on my website.
So, to be short: Real transformation only comes from the Holy Spirit:
Galatians 5:22-23
But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control […]
Conclusion
In Christianity, dependence on Christ is key. God is not a drill-instructor who demands that you work harder than everyone else, read more than everyone else, or chastise ourselves for not doing the right thing. God tells us that we cannot work through our own salvation. Instead we simply need to surrender to His will. Sometimes to do more means to do less.
Find a quit place where you don’t have to noise of that YouTube video buzzing around. Leave Rick Warren’s book on the shelf and open the Bible. Just read, stop and ask the Lord to enlighten you. Be still in the presence of the Lord.
Psalm 37:7
Be still before the Lord and wait patiently for him
In a culture that worships hustle and productivity, choosing rest in Christ is countercultural—but it’s also deeply freeing.
The journey away from self-reliance is a daily choice to surrender and trust in His strength. It’s moving from “I can do this myself” to “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me.” (Philippians 4:13)
The promise of self-help is that you can build a better you. The promise of the Gospel is that God is making you a new creation. One is about managing your own kingdom; the other is about surrendering to the King. One leads to exhaustion; the other leads to true rest. Jesus invites you to find rest in Him, not in your own striving.
But to find that rest in Christ you’ll also need to take another step in faith. You can click this on video below or go to the article on the website to find out how to do that.
